MichaelScottsman--LiquidAss-Frame/docs/phase2/wp/C7-review-R2.md

C7 People, Photos, Downloads, Store: quick review R2

Reviewer: independent agent (quick review R2, about 20 min, not a full audit). Package card: PLAN §2.4 "C7"; builder's log docs/phase2/wp/C7.md (Status "READY: wp.c7", 13:05). Main route: /chat (People), the card's first route. Flags on every step: --flags wp.c1a,wp.p3,wp.c7 (C7 plus its dependencies). Steam build 11094443. Out of scope (as asked): native sessions, removal sweeps, perf, full conformance, polish items.

Status

Done (2026-10-07, 16:43-17:00). Verdict accept: 0 blockers, 0 majors.

What was run

All CSS-only (native=off on every step line).

Id	Command	Result
R2-GL	gates main --route /chat --mode laser --flags wp.c1a,wp.p3,wp.c7 --shot p2_c7_r2_chat_laser (16:43)	PASS all five: MOTION, SIZE, TYPE, OUTLINE (4 edge probes, 22 pseudo-elements), AUD (0 findings, 6 exempt)
R2-GP	same, --mode pad --shot p2_c7_r2_chat_pad (16:49)	PASS all five, same counts
R2-BFS	pad-bfs --route /chat --mode pad --flags … (16:50), then --stock (16:51) for the baseline	Themed: 18 nodes, entry on the "Online Friends" group header, 9 exits all brought back by the overlay, 7 of 18 unreached, 13 irreversible moves. Stock: 18 nodes, entry on the open chat's invite button, 8 exits, 10 of 24 unreached, 15 irreversible moves. Both say FAIL for the same reason (Steam's own one-way moves between the friends list, the chat pane and the search field); the themed run has no new one-way move and a better entry. Not worse than stock. JSON in this session's scratchpad (c7r2_bfs_chat*.json)
R2-DL	gates main --route /library/downloads --mode laser --flags … --shot p2_c7_r2_dl_laser (16:57; extra, the builder ran Downloads only in pad)	PASS all five (AUD 0 findings, 1 exempt)
R2-RT	read device/rt/70-social.js (162 lines)	Sets only data-lgs-current and the /invites plate attributes and registers More hosts through C1a's helper; no click, dispatch, Steam setter, send, pause or remove call. Safe

Shots next to the mockups

• People (shots/p2_c7_r2_chat_laser.png, p2_c7_r2_chat_pad.png vs p2_social-media_people-t1.png): the 512 px black sidebar with the Large Title "Friends", the 60 px add-friend circle, the recessed segmented track with the white selected segment and the LB / RB circles, Title-weight group headers, large friend rows, the empty conversation pane on bare window glass, and the legend ornament under the window. Pad focus on the group header is the white focus platter with the specular, with A / B / ≡ glyphs in the legend; the laser legend has no glyphs. Glass slabs have no outlines. Different from the mockup, as recorded by the builder: icons only in the segments (no new strings), no search circle (C1a's capsule fallback), no compose placeholder. None of these is a break.
• Downloads (p2_c7_r2_dl_laser.png vs p2_social-media_downloads.png): Large Title, black platters for the queue and the completed row, Title 2 section headers without rules, the 60 px device capsule, a Clear All capsule, and the ornament legend (Change Device, Options, Go to game page, Back). No active download was present (none may be started), so the active card was not seen live.

Key functions

AUD has 0 GONE, HIDDEN or UNCLICKABLE on /chat in both modes and on Downloads under the laser. Gamepad reach on /chat is the same as stock or better. The friend tabs' LB / RB bumpers are laser-only in both themed and stock (Steam's focusable: false). The legends keep Options, Collapse and Back on /chat, and Change Device, Options, Go to game page and Back on Downloads.

Findings

None at blocker or major level.

Device left

• Theme on, CSS only.
• Every step used --flags and --mode, which are given back at the lock exit. /tmp/lgs/flags.json afterwards holds only another agent's key (wp.c5b), and no C7 key.
• No hv frames were taken (Frame /tmp/lgs/hv-*.png: 0).
• No dialog or menu was opened, and nothing was sent, bought, paused or cancelled.
• The route was /library/tab/AllGames at 16:56, set by another agent on the shared device.
• The pad-bfs runs found a conversation tab open in the friends UI. pad-bfs presses only the D-pad and B, and undoes any keyboard it opens, so this review did not open that tab, and the review left it as it was.